I have an old cat who has chronic renal failure and, I suspect, is a tad senile. She will poop in her litter boxes but she does number one on carpet or other soft absorbent surface. We (my cat and I) are now living in the non-carpeted part of the house. I have been using Iris brand training pads and was anxious to compare their performance with these pads. For my cat I place a small folded blanket on the vinyl floor and cover it with a training pad. I use the blanket because my cat seeks out cushy (which equates to absorbent in her tiny mind) places to pee on. The system has been working well for us. Because my cat has CRF she drinks a lot of water. She holds it until she is about to burst and so she puts out a lot of urine all at once. The training pads have to work hard to keep up and both brands do an acceptable job most times depending of course on how close to the edge of the pad she squats. I am home a lot and when I go out, three times a week, I am only away for two hours. So the pads are used only once and in our situation I can't imagine them being able to hold more. I used to immediately go to deal with the pad as soon as it was used but I've learned to wait at least a few minutes because the pad needs time to fully absorb making for a tidier pick-up and dispose process. These pads are a few inches larger than the medium sized Iris pads and they have a smoother slicker waterproof backing. Also these pads are fluffier and the absorbent side feels more cloth-like than the Iris. Bought in 100 count packs from Amazono the Iris pad are around 22 cents each and these pads in the 50 count pack are about 25 cents. If these pads out-performed the Iris or if the larger size mattered to me then I would switch brands. But the two brands are equally effective and the Iris are large enough for my purposes so I will stick with them. I thought the softer cloth-like feel of the Pruven pads would cause my cat to prefer them but she usually picks the Iris one to go on.
Just recently, I got a new puppy. Though, I'd been using training pads before that, (Sergeant and Out! pads) for one of my male cat's who likes to urinate outside of the box. I picked these out because, they had attractant on them and the Sergeant pads, I had used didn't have it.
My puppy has been using these probably 75% of the time, more than he went on the unscented pads. It seems like the attractant helps, along with praising him each time he uses them. They seem to be very absorbant and so far they haven't leaked through the plastic backing.
Though, before I got these in the mail, I found another brand with attractant (Out! training pads) at my local Family Dollar for $4.00 for 14 padscompared to $7.98 for these. These are the same size as the Out! pads at 21"x 23". The Out! pads are also quilted and the Pruven pads are not quilted, and they seem lighterweight, so the puppy is more apt to drag them off when he walks off the pad.
Overall, these work and they work well, but, I do think they are quite expensive. When I compare $4.00 to almost $8.00 and the fact that these are not quilted, I won't be switching over brands, as the Out! works as well for my puppy's and my cat's needs and also has an attractant.
Buy Pruven PP-14 21 by 23-Inch Super Absorbent Training Pads Now
Our use for a puppy pad are perhaps a little different than most; we have two older small seven pound Maltese brothers who are now 15 years old. As the years have progressed their faculties, eyesight and mobility, have been hampered by their age but their little spirits remain strong. They still romp about like puppies from time to time and they enjoy their daily treats with gusto. Unfortunately, their house training has been slipping their minds of late and the occasional accident seems now inevitable. So rather than treating these as training pads, we use them as little 'gardens' to save stress on all concerned.
We currently buy Nature's Miracle No Tracking Absorbent Training Pads, 100 Count Box which our dogs use almost without fail. It saves us admonishing little dogs in their twilight years and also having to mop up our kitchen frequently. Therefore we're happy with the status quo but granted it's not a perfect scenario but considering the alternative it's okay.
So given the chance to try a different brand was interesting. First thing I noticed was the Pruven pads were just a tiny bit smaller than the Nature's miracle. Only an inch or two but noticeably so. Plus they're pure white, even the borders, so when I placed it down on our white tiled kitchen floor with light colored grout it virtually disappeared. I may be wrong in this line of thinking but the strong deep outer green border on the nature's miracle I think acts as a boundary limit and our dogs seem to confirm this. Without the distinction I felt their aim might be a little off. Of course if your kitchen floor is a different color then the white may act as an encouragement for your little one.
Secondly the Pruven seemed to be not as thick and whilst that doesn't initially necessarily mean they're any less absorbent sadly in our case seems it does.
As I suspected the first night proved that aim was off, with several splashes outside the area. This could be due to the smaller size or indeed the chameleon nature of the white floor and white puppy pad. The absorbancy was also not as good with actual drips coming through the back after just three 'visits'. The Nature's Miracle brand can withstand many more uses than that before replacement and a larger puppy could possibly result in one visit per pad with the Pruven brand.
Ultimately in our case these didn't work as well as desired. Of course as originally pointed out, our criteria is a little different but given that these are more expensive that the ones we currently use, are smaller and seemingly not as absorbent then I just can't recommend them as they stand.
Read Best Reviews of Pruven PP-14 21 by 23-Inch Super Absorbent Training Pads Here
We use the BREEZE Cat Litter System for our 7 year-old female cat and it works very well; it utilizes a lower-tier tray that holds a pad to absorb the urine that passes through the upper-tier pellet litter. We received a sample of the Pruven 21 x 23 inch pads to test out with our cat who occasionally misses when using her box: we tried substituting the Pruven pad for the Breeze pad first, and then we also tested them around the box.
Results: as a Breeze-pad substitute, the Pruven pads are not as absorbent...but the comparison is not a very fair one since the Breeze pads are about twice as expensive. The Pruven pads worked better as general floor pads to catch the errant oversprays.
We took off a star because the pads are a bit costly since they run about $8 for 14 pads. Compare this to IRIS Neat n Dry Floor Protection and Training Pads for Puppies and Dogs, 200-Count which run about $50 for 200 pads.
If your pet has a chronic need, the latter product might make more sense.
Want Pruven PP-14 21 by 23-Inch Super Absorbent Training Pads Discount?
We've been using Simple Solutions Simple Solution Puppy Training Pads, 100 Count since our first Yorkie came home six years ago, with brief dalliances with other brands. We always end up going back to Simple Solutions and trying Pruven hasn't changed that pattern. We now have two Yorkies and go through a lot of training pads since they are virtually indoor dogs unless they are going for a walk on a leash (we have too many types of wild predators that would make snacks of our dogs to let them be outside on their own). Simple Solutions are thinner, slightly bigger and reduce the odor better than the others we have tried, including Pruven.
Pros:
white which looks nicer than beige (Simple Solutions) or blue (Petco brand)
Cons:
thicker
slightly smaller and every inch makes a difference
odor seemed stronger with these
Couldn't beat the price! Exactly what I was looking for. I have a young male Doberman who was sensitive to a chain choke collar. Very effective training aid.
