I have golden retrievers, and one of them needed this. Badly. It has completely eliminated his barking, at least when I'm home and from what my neighbors have told me. Unlike the Cairn terrier in the other post, my golden has decided he's not taking ANY chances, so if the collar is on, he's quiet. I have no idea if the battery is dead, and I rarely attempt to refill it.
I'm guessing the success of this really depends on the dog, and how badly it feels the need to bark.
I hate to admit that I used the bark shock collar years ago on another dog, and, while it was effective, I felt it was cruel. I never feel guilty about using this one. In fact, it was funny to watch his reaction the first few times he got sprayed.
We have a 7 lb Maltese who barks quite alot. We've tried shaking stones in a can, spraying water in his face, smacking newspaper on a hard surface....none worked! This collar does work. He doesnt' like the smell of the citronella or being sprayed. But the unit on the collar is large for these smaller dogs. I wish the company wold develop a smaller sized unit for smaller dogs.
Buy Intellipet Citronella Anti-Bark Dog Collar Now
The first thing I noted was how poorly the adjustable collar was set up. My cairn terrier immediately was able to undo it and get it off--after which, he began to chew it up. To deal with the bad neck circumference adjusting mechanism, I used a very small plastic tie instead, and trimmed it short with the sharp side facing out. This did the trick, and since my dog was the only one who would ever wear it, I didn't have to worry about changing the length again. I also did the same operation for my father's 6 collars (same brand) for his large Bouvier dogs. The spray mechanism is rather big for a small cairn terrier, but it does work and doesn't seem to be too weighty. Caution: whistle in the speaker of collar to test if it works each time. My dog is smart enough to check for himself and will bark himself silly if the citronella has run out (which it does a lot!!!) or the battery is dead. Keep extra cans of citronella and batteries on hand, or you will regret it. I use this collar on my dog daily, so I check it each time because my neighbors are raw over his incessant barking. Hope this is helpful.
Read Best Reviews of Intellipet Citronella Anti-Bark Dog Collar Here
Works great! I have never used a shock collar, but this collar really helps my dog. Especially at the dog park when they get fixated on something or some dog and I need an easy way to get them to refocus.
Please do no think this means it will help a dog with problems at the park though. Mine are well trained but one is old and hard of hearing and the other is a young rescue. I made sure they are not aggressive and listen to me, but at big dog parks where they can separate easy it works for me.
Want Intellipet Citronella Anti-Bark Dog Collar Discount?
I purchased the wrong color, however, I did give it to a friend who has a female puppy and her complaint was that It's too small.
